After an owner transfer, people with shared access are not told where the shared item now appears (#1073 follow-up) #1084

Open
opened 2026-11-03 05:32:17 +00:00 by Cordy · 0 comments
Owner

Context. Since #835 an owner transfer re-points every grant and link to the new owner, and since #1056 the grantees' locks and open editors follow the files. The path changes, though: Bob's /shared/anna/Projekte becomes /shared/eva/Projekte.

Today.

  • The new owner gets the share-links-handed bell. The grantees get nothing.
  • Their access, role, locks and editor sessions are unchanged, but the item simply shows under another owner's name.
  • Bookmarks and written paths name the old owner.
  • The change feed reports a delete at the old root and a write at the new one; since #1074 the write carries the item id.
  • Not verified end to end: a WebDAV mount or sync root bound to /shared/anna/... probably sees the folder vanish and a new one appear.

WebDAV locks carried to a path the client does not know (decision A on #1073):

  • A grantee's dav lock is carried by the transfer. The client still knows the old URL, so it can neither refresh nor use the lock.
  • The lock still binds others at the new path until it expires, at most 1 hour.
  • RFC 4918 §6.1 item 8 would delete a lock whose lock-root becomes unmapped.
  • v0.6.391 documents this in users-access.md.

To decide (research first):

  • Tell the grantee: one bell per grantee per transfer, for example "Projekte, shared with you by anna, is now shared by eva. Your access did not change." (wording to approve). Optionally a line in the transfer dialog.
  • The dav lock: keep carrying it (and tell the grantee), or release it with the grouped bell, or keep an alias of the old /shared/<owner> URL for a while.
  • Check clients: what WebDAV clients, sync roots and bound devices (#897) see.

Refs: #1073 (mockup open point 7, decision A), #1056, #835, #1063, #1074, research-1073.md §6.4, research-1073-unsettled.md §8 A.

**Context.** Since #835 an owner transfer re-points every grant and link to the new owner, and since #1056 the grantees' locks and open editors follow the files. The path changes, though: Bob's `/shared/anna/Projekte` becomes `/shared/eva/Projekte`. **Today.** - The new owner gets the `share-links-handed` bell. The grantees get nothing. - Their access, role, locks and editor sessions are unchanged, but the item simply shows under another owner's name. - Bookmarks and written paths name the old owner. - The change feed reports a delete at the old root and a write at the new one; since #1074 the write carries the item id. - Not verified end to end: a WebDAV mount or sync root bound to `/shared/anna/...` probably sees the folder vanish and a new one appear. **WebDAV locks carried to a path the client does not know** (decision A on #1073): - A grantee's `dav` lock is carried by the transfer. The client still knows the old URL, so it can neither refresh nor use the lock. - The lock still binds others at the new path until it expires, at most 1 hour. - RFC 4918 §6.1 item 8 would delete a lock whose lock-root becomes unmapped. - v0.6.391 documents this in users-access.md. **To decide (research first):** - **Tell the grantee:** one bell per grantee per transfer, for example "Projekte, shared with you by anna, is now shared by eva. Your access did not change." (wording to approve). Optionally a line in the transfer dialog. - **The `dav` lock:** keep carrying it (and tell the grantee), or release it with the grouped bell, or keep an alias of the old `/shared/<owner>` URL for a while. - **Check clients:** what WebDAV clients, sync roots and bound devices (#897) see. Refs: #1073 (mockup open point 7, decision A), #1056, #835, #1063, #1074, research-1073.md §6.4, research-1073-unsettled.md §8 A.
Sign in to join this conversation.
No labels
No project
No assignees
1 participant
Notifications
Due date
The due date is invalid or out of range. Please use the format "yyyy-mm-dd".

No due date set.

Dependencies

No dependencies set.

Reference: Cordy/Cairn#1084
No description provided.