Revoke all of a departed owner writes no per-share share-ended record for federated shares (#1057 decision; decide) #1088

Open
opened 2026-11-03 05:32:30 +00:00 by Cordy · 0 comments
Owner

Revoke all of a departed owner ends their federated shares out with no per-share audit record. This follows #1057 S6, "no share-ended record", as for the grants and links it removes (internal/api/owners.go endFed(..., "owner-revoke", ...)). The only entry is one owner-revoke with Path /home/<owner>, which names no share.

Since v0.6.392 (#1072 final review S2, fail-safe): owner-revoke is one of the verbs the restore checklist reads. Any owner-revoke between the backup and the declaration makes the Federated shares lists "the audit log for that time is incomplete".

Decision needed. Two options:

  • Write a record per share: share-ended reason=owner-revoke ocm=<pid> recipient=<addr> told=pending by=<admin> for each share in endFed, then drop the fallback for entries from that version on. This changes #1057 S6 and adds one admin-tier line per federated share to a Revoke all.
  • Keep the fallback only.

Research by the playbook first (audit expectations: ISO 27001 A.8.15, NIST AU-2/AU-12, GDPR Art. 19), then ask.

**Revoke all** of a departed owner ends their federated shares out with no per-share audit record. This follows #1057 S6, "no share-ended record", as for the grants and links it removes (`internal/api/owners.go` `endFed(..., "owner-revoke", ...)`). The only entry is one `owner-revoke` with Path `/home/<owner>`, which names no share. **Since v0.6.392 (#1072 final review S2, fail-safe):** `owner-revoke` is one of the verbs the restore checklist reads. Any `owner-revoke` between the backup and the declaration makes the Federated shares lists "the audit log for that time is incomplete". **Decision needed.** Two options: - **Write a record per share:** `share-ended reason=owner-revoke ocm=<pid> recipient=<addr> told=pending by=<admin>` for each share in `endFed`, then drop the fallback for entries from that version on. This changes #1057 S6 and adds one admin-tier line per federated share to a Revoke all. - **Keep the fallback only.** Research by the playbook first (audit expectations: ISO 27001 A.8.15, NIST AU-2/AU-12, GDPR Art. 19), then ask.
Sign in to join this conversation.
No labels
No project
No assignees
1 participant
Notifications
Due date
The due date is invalid or out of range. Please use the format "yyyy-mm-dd".

No due date set.

Dependencies

No dependencies set.

Reference: Cordy/Cairn#1088
No description provided.